N172 Old Judge script series

[RCMcKenzie]

I try and buy the script series cards as they come up for sale and saw a Jack Lynch pose 282-4 on ebay going for under one hundred dollars. www.ebay.com/itm/130864343856

It was ending during work hours today, so I dropped a cover all bids bid of $500 last night. This morning I noticed that it had already been topped, so I bid again at $680 thinking surely that would do it, but it sold for $1009 and I was second underbidder.

My question is about the pricing of this card. Is Lynch difficult, or was the pose difficult, or did 3 people just want to buy it? I can usually pick up non-superstar script cards in the 250-500 range.

[oldjudge]

As you know, all script cards are somewhat difficult. This Lynch pose is tougher than most and is on several advanced collector's want lists. Despite the paper loss on the front I think it was a good buy at the final price.

[Matthew H]

It looks like it might be rebacked, and the corner might fall off... It had a nice photo though, for a script series card.

[RCMcKenzie]

Thanks for the feedback, Jay. I was wondering if I had inadvertently caused the price to jump by bidding too early, as it seems that no reserve ebay auctions often double in the last 10 seconds. At any rate, I will try and post a few script cards that I have on here later today.

I was able to get 2 Diamond S and 1 Number 7 Cigar from the same seller in low grade at prices that were lower than I had expected to pay. I guess it's all about supply and demand.

[Matthew H]

My question is about the pricing of this card. Is Lynch difficult, or was the pose difficult, or did 3 people just want to buy it? I can usually pick up non-superstar script cards in the 250-500 range.

Lynch is found only in the script series set. The other guys can be found other years. (With the exception of some spotted ties)

[RCMcKenzie]

Lynch is found only in the script series set. The other guys can be found other years. (With the exception of some spotted ties)
Matthew,

Thanks for the reply. Yes, I learned about that this morning. After my $500 bid was overtaken, I looked up the Lynch card in the OJ book to try and see what was going on and saw that his card only came in the script series.

To use a skiing analogy I consider myself an intermediate, or blue slope OJ collector, but I do like to buy the script series cards as they seem like a good value for what you get. The paper loss on the front stopped me from bidding higher, but I still would have been outbid on this one.

[uffda51]

http://photos.imageevent.com/uffda51/18871890n172oldjudge/websize/N172%20Lynch%20no%20team%20sm.jpg

Different pose of Lynch, picked up at the last National.

[RCMcKenzie]

That's a really nice example, Bruce. Thanks for posting it.

Here are 4 that I have. I was thinking I had 5 or 6 of these for some reason, but I only have these four. The higher grade ones are recently from Jay. The trimmed Gerhardt and Esterbrook were bought separately on ebay 8 - 10 years ago.

9254192542

9254392544