1954 Brooklyn ball -- clubhouse sigs??

[earlywynnfan]

I just opened a really cool group of team-signed baseballs, which is a little out of my realm. I love this 1954 Bum ball. Can anyone help me figure out which are clubhouse sigs? I am unfamiliar with who used clubhouse guys and who are legit.

The Hodges is next to another Hodges I have, and I believe the one on the right is correct.

Thanks, Ken

[JayZim13]

A good sign that a ball has many clubhouse signatures is when there is a panel signed by Jacky, Campy and Erskine

[keithsky]

I totally agree with JayZim. Was always told Jackie, Campy, Erskine on the same panel was clubhouse. Oh Charlie DiGiovanna you little devil.

[RichardSimon]

100% correct Jay (I think I taught him that) :),,, Robinson, Campy, Erskine in a row on one panel, means clubhouse signed ball.

[earlywynnfan]

Thanks, guys, this is what I expected. I have to admit, I did get a thrill at pulling this one out of the box!

I do have a follow-up, though. Did he sign the entire ball, or are the common guys real? What about Alston or Snider?

Thanks, Ken

[RichardSimon]

On a quick once over only, I think they all are signed by the "little devil."

[earlywynnfan]

Thank you. Man, he was good!

Ken