Would you mind tendering your opinions on Aaron, Williams, DiMaggio and Mantle balls?

[Scott Garner]

I would appreciate your opinions on these 4 signed balls- Hank Aaron, Ted Williams, Joe DiMaggio and the Mick. These represent day 2 of a large collection of signed balls that my friend Shawn has been offered. These are the last 4 that I will ask about. Thanks in advance for your thoughts! :)

[Sean1125]

I don't like the Dimaggio...

[Mr. Zipper]

Not sure on the Aaron, but in my opinion the other three are bad.

[thetruthisoutthere]

I would appreciate your opinions on these 4 signed balls- Hank Aaron, Ted Williams, Joe DiMaggio and the Mick. These represent day 2 of a large collection of signed balls that my friend Shawn has been offered. These are the last 4 that I will ask about. Thanks in advance for your thoughts! :)

Scott, tell your Shawn to find someone else to purchase autographed baseballs from....

[mr2686]

Williams and Dimaggio are bad, and the Aaron looks bad to me...and I always freeze up when it comes to Mantle but I'd use the Jim Stinson drop of Piss test for the whole group. :D

[Bestdj777]

I am still learning to spot fake Mantles but I would not touch that one. The K looks really off to me, and it looks slowly drawn. And, I don't know about anyone else but the fact they are shrink wrapped bothers me a bit.

[isaac2004]

Williams and Dimaggio are bad, and the Aaron looks bad to me...and I always freeze up when it comes to Mantle but I'd use the Jim Stinson drop of Piss test for the whole group. :D

+1

[Scott Garner]

Thanks a lot to everyone for your opinions. I suspected that all of these looked fishy.
Chris, I will pass along your advice.
Best,
Scott

[shelly]

Scott, One dead giveaway with the Williams ball is an open d or a. This has an open d. The Mantle is really easy, shakes and quarter moon M's:)

[murphusa]

they look like the typical North Jersey verity