Local Auction House- Are theses Cards Real?

[ibuysportsephemera]

Hi guys, below is a link to a local auction house. There are a few cards, some autographs and memorabilia. Is there any chance that the Mantle and Mathewson are real? I don't do cards so I am just curious. If by some crazy chance they are, you might get a good deal. I have no affiliation with the auction house and am not promoting this in anyway.

http://www.jenack.com/viewauction.aspx?a=393

Jeff

[Leon]

I don't know Topps fakes as well but the Matty looks good from the scan. I don't see any blatant fakes in the auction. (I could have missed something as I only looked for a minute)

[ullmandds]

looks good to me...atleast the vintage...don't know about the 50's stuff.

[CobbSpikedMe]

I agree with Leon. I don't know how to tell if the Mantle is real or not, but it looks good to me and the Matty looks good for sure to me.

Best,

AndyH



.

[vintagerookies51]

The Matty and Gehrig look good. I don't know if it's the scan but the front of the Mantle looks off to me.

[e107collector]

The 51 Bowman Mantle looks to be fake in my honest opinion. The borders look too big, and color appears to be off.

Just my 2 cents.

Tony

[Tiger Eye]

As a long time lurker in the shadows, I can finally speak to something I have experience with. That 1951 Bowman Mantle is almost positively a fake. The face is too red. Unforunately, many years ago,before I stumbled on this Site, I purchased one. I keep it as a example of making a purchase before you know what you are doing. It was an expensive lesson,but one I learned well.

[drc]

The Mantle looked a bit bright, so I'd double check that. The other pics are small and I did a quick look throuigh, but I didn't see any obvious reprints, including the Topps. I've never heard of reprints of the blankets (#1). If they're felt, I'd assume those are legit.

[vintagerookies51]

Pretty sure I saw the exact same Matty in a LiveAuctioneers auction... isn't this the same card as lot #14 in the "local auction"? http://www.liveauctioneers.com/item/12969601_1909-11-t206-christy-mathewson-baseball-card

[dbrown]

That's the same auction, just listed on liveauctioneers.