Slabbed CJ Wagner--real or fake?

[obcmac]

On ebay with a good seller and real bids...

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Hans-Honus-Wagner-1915-Cracker-Jack-Not-T206-Hans-Wagner-Sgc-A-HOF-/280906582589

Same cert, but looks different than the one attached...am I too parnoid?

I just asked the seller about it...lots of good deals with him (hope I saved myself instead of cost myself money).

Mac

[dog*dirt]

I believe it is the same card, it is just the scan on ebay is not as clear. My reasoning is that there is a scratch on the case on the lower left portion of both pics if you look close. Just my opinion.

[buymycards]

Wow, sure doesn't look like the same card.

[4815162342]

The eBay scan looks like a case of over-sharpening the image.

[Leon]

Agreed. Poor ebay scan and same card. Nice card too.

[obcmac]

Got a friendly email back saying that it was the same card...now I'm wondering about all those CJ's I've avoided based on the scans.

[Sixtofan]

That is really interesting, I never bid when the scans look like that. Clearly I have a lot to learn

[esd10]

i can understand why you are nervous it looks fake from the scans

[Republicaninmass]

Seller is A-ok