Needed opinions on sgc 84 joe doyle (lot#152 goodwin)

[CMIZ5290]

I really need this card for my set, but have no clue why sgc gave it the grade they did. Looks very overgraded.. Am i missing something?

[sportscardpete]

Corners aren't "razor sharp".

[pgellis]

Here's SGCs description of their grading scale:

SGC84/7: 70/30 or better centering, slight wear on some corners, minor scratching, some print spots or speckling, and print lines or refractor lines are acceptable. Card may exhibit a slightly skewed (diamond) cut.


I would say that their description is accurate with regard to that Doyle card. "Slight wear on some corners".