Eddie Mathews/Billy Martin autograph opinion?

[vintagerookies51]

My grandma gave these to me a few years ago. She said my grandpa went to a 1953 baseball game between the "Service All Stars" and "Lopat's All Stars" (Ed Lopat) and got these autographs. I have a whole program dated November, 1953 (could post pictures if you guys want me to) and has pictures of all the famous MLB players on Lopat's team, along with a few pages of the two rosters. With all this provenance, I assume they're real but I know nothing about autographs so I could use some help. Thanks!

http://i904.photobucket.com/albums/ac244/vintagerookies51/024.jpg

[perezfan]

Good as gold :D

[Lordstan]

I think they're both good.
Considering his later life behavior I think that is a great inscription on the Martin.

[GrayGhost]

Looks just like my vintage Billy:)

Great looking signatures sir.

[canjond]

Good

[David Atkatz]

Your grandmother says your grandfather got the autographs in person, and you doubt her?
Shame on you. ;)

[daves_resale_shop]

Very Cool piece Scott...
The Martin inscription is borderline eerie!