"csa 8.5 = psa 6.5"..??!!

[Edwolf1963]

http://cgi.ebay.com/Ty-Cobb-T206-Bat-Off-Shoulder-Graded-CSA-8-5-PSA-6-5-/220722328246?pt=US_Baseball&hash=item33641372b6

This looks familiar, not the first time I've seen this card. Love the opinion of grade cross-over stated as fact.

I thought most CSA graded cards come back trimmed from SGC, PSA, BVG?

[Bridwell]

I've cracked out a few CSA's and submitted to PSA. About half were trimmed, and about half were graded but down 1-2 grades. This Cobb would be an enormous gamble.

[tbob]

I've cracked out a few CSA's and submitted to PSA. About half were trimmed, and about half were graded but down 1-2 grades. This Cobb would be an enormous gamble.

I agree. Would look nice in an SGC AUT holder though.

[HRBAKER]

Many moons ago I bought 3 CSA graded cards. They all 3 crossed to SGC at the exact same grade. That was several generations of holders ago (back when they looked very similar to the PSA holder).

[Anthony S.]

Depends how sharp the X-Acto Knife was that day.

[barrysloate]

The fact that a T206 Cobb in 8.5 is only at $830 suggests a serious lack of bidder confidence. A PSA 8.5 would be many multiples higher.

[glchen]

I once purchased 3 CSA N162's, and they came back from SGC as rebacked.

[B O'Brien]

I am pretty sure I have seen that card before too.

I bought a CSA 8 last year for about the same money as a nice SGC A, which is a good thing since it was a SGC A!

Over the years I am 3 for 5 trimmed when cracking and those.

Hope all is well,
Bob

[chaddurbin]

seller won't accept a return on the card...that's how confident he is it'd cross.

[shimozukawa]

.

[Bridwell]

The first link is the one we are referring to. Their website hasn't been updated since 2007. They may be out of business.

The 2nd one is a Canadian company. Never heard of them in the pre-war market. There used to be a grading company called KSA, that was from Canada and did some pre-war baseball grading. Perhaps KSA and CSA are connected somehow.

[calvindog]

That card is obviously trimmed.

[Bilko G]

that card is obviously trimmed.


this ^^^^^