PCL Card help Mothers Cookies, Remar Baking, Zeenuts

[JamesGallo]

I picked up a batch of these cards and honestly know nothing about them beyond what it says in the guide and in Old Carboard. Any pricing and rarity help would be great, although I think they are all commons, I just don't know if the guide is right on the pricing.


Mothers Cookies

All cards are G-VG or less.

1952 Mothers Cookies

3-Gettel
9-Marshall
30-Schenz
31-Gilbert
33-Chapman
34-Ragni

1953 Mothers Cookies

5-Robbe
8-Peterson
10-Pocekay
11-Tornay
15-Myers
16-Howerton
17-Stevens
28-Milne Outfielder x2
33-Cheso
35-Pieretti
38-Bamberger
42-Hittle
45-Tobin
50-Richards
52-Welmaker
54-Davis
55-Jorgensen
58-Lynn
59-Bockman

Remar Baking

These are nicer VG-EX or better

1947-Soriano

1948
Duezabou
Lavagetto
Scarsella

1949

Bamberger
Gettel
Hamrick
Hofman
Lavagetto
Rapp


Zeenuts

All these are couponless and likely trimmed a bit too.

1921 Zeenuts
O'Doul

1924 Zeenuts
Ivan Howard
Cather

1931 Zeenuts
Powers

Thanks

James G

[Jacklitsch]

Don't know a whole lot about the Mother's Cookies. I've purchased Remars for $10-$15. The 21 zeenut O'Doul is on a couple wantlists that I'm aware of including mine. Tough card. Dibs.

jacklitsch@comcast.net

[rhettyeakley]

Steve, it is unclear what you are dibs-ing so I'll call dibs specifically on the '21 Zeenut O'Doul!:D

I could also use the '24 Crandall should it present decently. Nothing too special in the Mothers Cookies lot you have, they are collected but eye appeal is somewhat tough on these as they are often found beat up and stained (from the cookies). The '53's tend to show up more frequently and in higher grades tahn the '52's. The Remars are all pretty easy with the '49's being the most common of all the years IMO. The best Mothers card you have in the group is the 1953 Davis as that is the former Negro Leaguer Piper Davis (he also has Toleteros cards, etc.)

[Chris Counts]

The cards of Piper Davis and Roy Welmaker always seems to sell for at least 50 percent more than the other Mothers Cookies you have listed because they both had significant careers in the Negro Leagues ...

[rhettyeakley]

There is also a card in the 1952 Mothers Cookies set that features Negro Leaguer Bob Thurman as well, as it is a 1952 it is tougher than the other two mentioned.