1910 Newspaper Contest

[D. Broughman]

How many of these players can our members name from this August 7, 1910 Boston Sunday Post Newspaper Contest.

[ullmandds]

101...Matty!

[iggyman]

#107 = Otto "t206" Knabe

Lovely Day...

[asoriano]

#1: Howie Camnitz
#7: Lefty Leifield
#27: Doc Marshall
#28: Chief Meyers
#30: Red Dooin
#31: Amby McConnell
#36: Larry Doyle
#59: Dennis Sullivan
#68: Fred Merkle
#96: Eddie Grant

[barrysloate]

78- Johnny Evers. Picture is kind of small.

Now I think I'm wrong...4 looks like Evers. I need a better pair of eyes.

[Section103]

77 is Joe Kelley.

[rhettyeakley]

Wow, my eyes hurt! we need a larger image to see some the smaller ones but some are fairly obvious...who wouldn't recognize Joe Kelley's balding pattern on #77!

[rholmes]

#80 jumps out at me as Josh Devore...pose from E94.

[rhettyeakley]

#4 Evers
#5 Rucker
#7 Leifield
#20 Reulbach
#39 Kling
#78 Evers (again)
#108 Wagner

[T206Collector]

#1 - Howie Camnitz (Arms Folded - same as T206 image) I think it's close enough for government work, as they say.

[asoriano]

Anybody else think that #68 is Fred Merkle?

[ullmandds]

10 Herzog...yep Rhett...kelley's balding pattern is unmistakable!

[rholmes]

Taking the liberty of re-posting collage so we don't have to go back to previous page to look at it :).

http://img710.imageshack.us/img710/6853/1910contest.jpg

[barrysloate]

Has the contest expired yet? Are we still eligible for the prize?

[slantycouch]

Anybody else think that #68 is Fred Merkle?

I of course instantly thought of the image from his T206 (http://bit.ly/ddibQx) and said yes...

Seems like it to me, but the image is pretty small!

[bobbvc]

#74 looks like George Gibson

[Jantz]

A few more not yet IDed

40 - Ed Karger or Lajoie (not sure)
103 - Jim Pastorius
85 - Harry Steinfeldt
99 - Dots Miller

[judsonhamlin]

3 is Bush (T222)
7 is Krause (T206 throwing)
14 is Gibson (E93)
23 is (I think) Chase (also E93)
39 is Archer (T222)
40 is Karger (T206)
49 is Moore (E94)
66 is (I think) Devlin
107 is Knabe

[martyogelvie]

my eyes hurt..
but
101 is Mathewson
is 106 Hal Chase ?
40 - looks like wags to me..

[iggyman]

I think I see Joe Jackson! In the lower left / upper right quadrex; he is sliding back to first (reverse negative angle). I think he is wearing a Cleveland home jersey uniform???

Oh wait, wrong thread......

Lovely Day...

[Tom S.]

...looks like John McGraw to me.

[peterose4hof]

I have consolidated everyone's input into a list. Also I have cited which vintage card the picture is from if known.

1 Howie Camnitz (T206)
3 Bullet Joe Bush (T222)
4 Johnny Evers
5 Napolean Rucker (T3)
7 Lefty Leifield (T206) or Harry Krause (T206)
10 Buck Herzog
14 George Gibson (E93)
20 Ed Reuhlbach (T204)
27 Doc Marshall (T206)
28 Chief Meyers
30 Red Dooin (T3)
31 Amby McConnell (T3)
36 Larry Doyle (T3)
39 Jimmy Archer (T222)
40 Ed Karger (T206)
49 Earl Moore (E94)
59 Dennis Sullivan
66 Art Devlin
68 Fred Merkle
74 George Gibson ?
77 Joe Kelley (T206)
78 Johnny Evers
79 John McGraw
80 Josh Devore (T206 or E94)
85 Harry Steinfeldt
92 Hooks Wiltsie (E93)
96 Eddie Grant
97 Slim Sallee (T3)
99 Dots Miller (T206)
101 Christy Mathewson (T206)
103 Jim Pastorius (T206)
107 Otto Knabe (T206)
108 Honus Wagner

I don’t believe #23 is Hal Chase because he threw left handed and #23 is throwing with his right.

Anyone think #98 might be Sam Crawford?

I am pretty sure #92 is Hooks Wiltsie (E93)

#97 is Slim Sallee (T3)

[nolemmings]

50 looks like Ed Konetchy to me, and 59 looks like Germany Schaeffer

[Pup6913]

#24 street
#67 Wolter
#98 McGraw
#103 looks like Cobb getin smacked in the Nutz by 104:D


Just my guesses

[iggyman]

#093 T206 Jimmy Sheckard (no glove)
#095 T206 Harry Steinfeldt (batting)

Lovely Day...

[T206Collector]

Just to be clear -- the original poster has the key, right?

[D. Broughman]

Sorry no Key :o

[teetwoohsix]

The few that I could pick out have already been named, but #59 doesn't look like he's having a good day :D